Review topics: ["size","fit","length","shirt","color","waist","material","shorts","quality","look","style","pair","stretch","gap","curves","jeans","denim","body"].
Reviews
Strange fit
"Everlane sizing in pants/ shorts is kind of all over the place. I am a 27/28 in pants size, and always go with a 26 in Everlane since they tend to run large. Reviews for these said to size up, but I stuck with my normal size and they make me look like I am wearing a diaper. Strange cut, not like other Wayhigh pants that I have multiple pairs of. Bummed they are final sale."
— Mjam (2/5)
Cute summer denim shorts
"I snapped these up at 70% off because I thought 'why not'? I ordered my usual size, and I have about 5 pairs of Everlane jeans, all in 26. These are true to size but do have a waist gap while being snug around my butt and thighs. I can sit and walk and they're comfy enough, but I'm hoping they break in a bit more over time and become a bit softer and stretch out a tad, that would make them perfect. Would I be happy to pay full price for these? No. But on sale, they're great value."
— Terose (4/5)
Absolute shizzers. Not cool,Everlane. Not at all.
"I have three pairs of way high jeans, all 25. Bought these in 26 to be loose and comfy and they are a full size smaller than my jeans! At final sale, there’s a level of trust that they’re not so ridiculous they are unwearable. Really really annoyed. Not cool, Everlane. Not cool at all."
— Nsmleighton (1/5)
WAAAY TO SMALL
"I sized up as recommended and these short were still way too tight in the waist- nothing like the other high waisted everlane jeans I have purchased in the past. terrible"
— Gbhadley (1/5)
Tiny
"I'm pretty reliably a 23 in Everlane bottoms but the waist on these is so small I can't even wear them unless I find a way to stretch it out about an inch. I'd return but they were final sale."
— Luey (1/5)
Love these!
"I love these! They are just long enough and the perfect denim. They do fit more snug because they are cotton, and I’m happy with that. I know that the denim will stretch a bit over time, but if you prefer more give, maybe do a size up. I like a tighter fit. I’m 5’10, 25 waist, 36 hip and got size 25. These are my shorts of the summer!"
— Nicole P. (5/5)
My very favorite shorts
"I’m obsessed with these shorts. I first purchased one, and then came back for multiple colors. Really hope they keep this style - it’s the perfect longer length shirt that looks cute without looking too “mom” Jean"
— Memartin (5/5)
Not the same fit as the Bone
"I bought the darker color after LOVING these Way High shorts in Bone. The material and length are great, I was really disappointed that they are almost a completely different fit than the Bone despite being the same size. The Bone fits perfectly through my hips, waist, and butt. These are huge everywhere except the thighs and have a big waist gap. Love the length and the color, but I’ll probably have to get them taken in to wear them comfortably."
— Leanne V. (4/5)
Rigid and unflattering
"I rarely give poor reviews and I kept these shorts to try to break them in, but they never softened and stretched. The material is too rigid and thick for summer, so being high waisted they were not comfy. I had high hopes given plenty of good reviews but they are not what I expected."
— Emilyrose11201 (2/5)
no waist gap
"I'm a 5'3'' petite pear with prominent quads, and these jean shorts are the most flattering and comfortable jean shorts ever. I have no waist gap in spite of my pear shape, and the jeans look good cuffed or uncuffed, hitting at a flattering place on my leg."
— Petitepear (5/5)