womens / Shoes - Sandals, Boots, Sneakers & Flats

The Modern Loafer
$50
$168 $50
70% OFF FINAL SALE
  • womens-leather-modern-loafer-rum | primary
  • womens-leather-modern-loafer-rum | alt
  • womens-leather-modern-loafer-rum
  • womens-leather-modern-loafer-rum
  • womens-leather-modern-loafer-rum
  • womens-leather-modern-loafer-rum
womens-leather-modern-loafer-rum | primary
womens-leather-modern-loafer-rum | alt
womens-leather-modern-loafer-rum
womens-leather-modern-loafer-rum
womens-leather-modern-loafer-rum
womens-leather-modern-loafer-rum

womens / Shoes - Sandals, Boots, Sneakers & Flats

The Modern Loafer

$50
$168 $50
View full details

Sorry, this item is no longer available.

But keep an eye out—there's always a chance it will come back later.

Shop More Shoes

Overall rating: 4.292135 / 5 from 89 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

The Modern Loafer Rum shoes are praised for their beauty, craftsmanship, and timeless look. Customers appreciate the high-quality leather, sourced from a certified tannery, which is soft and comfortable. While opinions on sizing and fit vary, the overall quality and elegant style make these shoes a popular choice.

Summary topics

  • Craftsmanship (42%): Many customers stated that these shoes are beautiful, well-made, and elevate any outfit, making them a popular choice.
  • Product Quality (13%): Customers loved the great quality of these shoes, although some found the lack of support uncomfortable.
  • Comfort and Quality (18%): A significant number of customers appreciated the comfort and quality of these loafers, considering them the best they've ever worn.
  • Aesthetic Appeal (18%): A significant number of customers raved about the look, describing it as classy, elegant, and timeless.
  • Design Style (8%): It was reported by customers that the style of the product is loved and considered classic and sleek.

Review topics: ["size","fit","feel","problem","color","look","quality","shoe","style","comfort","design","loafer","leather","shape","loafers","foot","feet","support","blisters","break","silhouette","works","wear","made","everlane","socks","heel"].

Review highlights

  • "Love love these shoes amazing great quality" — angela c.
  • "These loafers look great and wear well." — Kimberly J.
  • "Classic style, great quality and comfortable form the go!" — Horn2

Reviews

Love the design, sadly construction quality is disappointing

"This is a great loafer that Everlane has been making for a few years. I am finding that the quality of the construction in their shoes has declined. I own many Everlane shoes and they have held up very well over several years, and the fit was great. This pair and a previous pair I recently purchased gap at the sides, especially when walking, which never happened before, the look and function of the shoe is poor. . I hope they will return to their pervious quality because I love Everlane and the design of their shoes is great! Sadly it was final sale, so I cannot return."

— Jan S. (3/5)

Impressed

"The loafers are high quality and exactly what I wanted. I ordered a half size larger than I normally do, as I didn't know what the fit would be like. While they are a bit big, with socks they will work. I am a fan!"

— Glenna E. (5/5)

Beautifully made, just not good for my feet.

"I really loved these shoes. They are well made of high quality materials. I’ve bought other Everlane shoes in size 8 that fit fine, but given that the leather is stiff and I have bunions, they hurt too much to wear so I sent them back. Like a lot of people with bunions, I have trouble finding workable shoes. I imagine they would be fine for someone without my problems, however."

— Lisa F. (4/5)

So happy with these loafers!

"These were on sale so I thought, why not try them? I’m so glad is did. They are so comfortable! I didn’t need to break them in at all. Bought my usual size 8. Highly recommend!"

— Rebecca S. (5/5)

I was SO excited that

"I was SO excited that I ordered two pairs of shoes I wanted. But you sent me the wrong size and didn’t give me any apologies or credit extra about it. I really love the style. It was disappointing. The silver flat I got are so beautiful. I love the material but didn’t wear yet."

— Mariana F. (1/5)

Too Narrow

"I’m disappointed in the final sale loafers I ordered. I ordered size 6M which is my size but they are too tight to wear. I did a chat & was told to try to stretch them by wearing them at home. I’ve done that now for weeks & still too tight."

— Georgeanne S. (1/5)

very good quality. very comfortable,

"very good quality. very comfortable, look elegant ."

— Lea E. (5/5)

Judged a book by its cover, that sort of purchase

"When it looks nice in photo but it looked a bit inexpensive side. Very hard feel and needs some break ins. I might need to take it for stretching at the cobbler. Not sure if the leather color will age darker and prettier in months but wish I had not purchased."

— Tomoe S. (3/5)

Stylish shoe

"Well made, stylish. Comfortable. Only complaint is it does run big and unable to return. I’m a true 9. It slips way off my foot when walking. Added some padding on the back and it’s more wearable now. Nice shoe, I would personally just say size down a half to a full size."

— Grace F. (4/5)

Comfort Out of the Box

"These were everything I'd hoped they'd be. True to size and a little wide for my not-quite-officially-narrow foot, there is room for cute socks and still comfortable enough to go barefoot. These required no breaking in. They are great for every occasion, exactly what I was looking for."

— Katherine B. (5/5)

Q&A

Better for You.
Better for You.
Better for You.
We believe your wardrobe should be effortless, luxurious, and crafted with real quality. That belief drives everything we do. We’ve done a lot over the past decade—but we’re just getting started. The journey toward better continues.