Leather Keyhole Flat
40% OFF
Regular price $107
Regular price $178 Sale price $107
PREVIOUSLY $198
Black Friday Exclusive
40% OFF
Skip to product information

Leather Keyhole Flat

40% OFF
Regular price $107
Regular price $178 Sale price $107
PREVIOUSLY $198
Black Friday Exclusive
Size

Free Shipping on all US orders

Free standard shipping $75+, Express shipping $120+ Shipping Details

Holiday Returns

Gifts ordered after 11/15, return by 1/22. Details

Style Advice

Need fit or styling advice? Chat Now

Description

A fresh alternative to a ballet flat

Featuring a soft, modern square toe, 1/4in heel, and a nappa leather bow tie with keyhole detail, it's the ultimate wear-with-everything flat. Made with soft, reconstituted leather for the outsole. Dress it up or down, there are no wrong answers.

Fit

  • Heel height: 1/4"
  • Soft wide square toe
  • 3mm recycled latex footbed

Materials & Care

Materials:
  • 100% Sheep Leather Upper
Did You Know? The leather in this shoe is sourced from a tannery rated Gold by the Leather Working Group (LWG)—the highest rating a tannery can receive for demonstrating best practices in environmental compliance, including water, waste, and chemical management.
Care:
  • Professionally Leather Clean Only.

Details

  • Made at Stella Golden Star Thai Binh in Vietnam.

Free Shipping on all US orders

Free standard shipping $75+, Express shipping $120+ Shipping Details

Holiday Returns

Gifts ordered after 11/15, return by 1/22. Details

Style Advice

Need fit or styling advice? Chat Now

Sustainability

Better Price

Price and feature comparison
Attribute Past Everlane Still Everlane
Price $198 $107
Cleaner Chemistry
Cleaner Leather
View full details

Overall rating: 4.189189 / 5 from 37 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

These Leather Keyhole Flats are versatile and comfortable, praised for their modern design and square toe. While opinions vary on the fit and leather quality, they are generally well-received for their stylish appeal.

Summary topics

  • Comfort and Style (30%): Many customers remarked that these flats are perfect, comfortable, and have a modern vamp to them.
  • Fit and Material (20%): The feedback is varied, with some praising the fit and material, while others complain about the leather being hard.
  • Leather Quality (40%): Opinions vary on the leather, with some finding it soft and flexible, while others find it hard and stiff.

Review topics: ["fit","color","material","shoe","shape","look","leather","flats","details","ballet","bow","sole","foot"].

Review highlights

  • "The leather is soft and the shoes are very comfortable." — Allene
  • "These flats caught my attention immediately-the tie top detail, the square toe, the tomato red leather. . . ." — Nomi2064
  • "Love these ballet flats with a higher vamp for a modern look, with the bow tie giving Mary Jane vibes." — Vicki H.

Reviews

Excellent flats, dreamy leather

"I adore these flats. The shape is so comfortable, and the small bow is perfectly placed to still be slip on without having to re-tie. I did size up a half size because my foot shape is less long and lean, and the half size up gives my toes more room without looking too long at all. The 9 fit like a glove, and probably would have formed to my foot beautifully, but I like more room, leaning towards a barefoot-shoe roominess for my toes."

— Laura G. (5/5)

"Super cute really love the shape and the bow strap. Unfortunately they’re pretty uncomfortable and hurt my big toe. The leather doesn’t seem very nice. The red color rubs off and transfers to my socks. And one shoe came with glue still all over the sole and toe box. Slightly disappointed"

— Bella (3/5)

The cutest

"Needed a good leather flat option so I could walk around with no issue. These fit the bill! They are secure on my feet and so comfortable. I am obsessed with the red - such a fun pop!"

— Julie S. (5/5)

I LOVE these shoes, they

"I LOVE these shoes, they are gorgeous and are an easy way to add interest to any outfit. They run slightly big but are extremely comfortable right out of the box, I haven’t gotten any blisters even after wearing them all day. I get compliments every time I wear them."

— Daniela M. (5/5)

Great brown cute but….

"The shoes is a great brown color but the tie detail did not sit properly and seemed in the way. Sadly returning"

— jennifer c. (1/5)

Weird fit, sticky inside

"These do not fit well on a narrow foot. The inside of the shoe is weirdly sticky."

— Michal D. (5/5)

Beautiful and so comfy

"Comfortable right out of the box! Soft and lovely black leather with nice cushion. I’m usually between a 7. 5 and 8. I ordered the 7. 5 and they are perfect. Great to catch these cute and updated silhouette ballet flats on a sale price. Perfect office shoes."

— Rebecca L. (5/5)

Wonderful buttery stylish product

"Really elegant product that goes so well with all pants. I did find the fit very large though compared to the Day Glove - i wear a 10. 5 for Day Glove but it was too loose on me. Thankfully it can be slightly tightened using the ribbon, and i will probably have to put an inner sole"

— Audrey H. (5/5)

Overall great

"Needed to be broken in but after the first time I wore them, they were fine. Love these. The material is a bit thin and it might not last too long, but I got them on sale and they are cute for the price. They were true to size for me and not too narrow. There is no arch support but I do like the soft feel of the material. Was a little nervous since the were final sale, but I love them and can’t beat for the price."

— Claire W. (5/5)

too big

"the shoes are cute, but they’re slightly too big even though I’m an 8. 5. I got horrible blisters"

— Meghan W. (2/5)

Q&A

Better for You.
Better for You.
Better for You.
We believe your wardrobe should be effortless, luxurious, and crafted with real quality. That belief drives everything we do. We’ve done a lot over the past decade—but we’re just getting started. The journey toward better continues.