womens / Shoes - Sandals, Boots, Sneakers & Flats

The Day Mary Jane
$51
$128 $51
Shop more Day collection.
60% OFF FINAL SALE
  • womens-leather-day-mary-jane-peyote | primary
  • womens-leather-day-mary-jane-peyote | alt
  • womens-leather-day-mary-jane-peyote
  • womens-leather-day-mary-jane-peyote
  • womens-leather-day-mary-jane-peyote
  • womens-leather-day-mary-jane-peyote
  • womens-leather-day-mary-jane-peyote
womens-leather-day-mary-jane-peyote | primary
womens-leather-day-mary-jane-peyote | alt
womens-leather-day-mary-jane-peyote
womens-leather-day-mary-jane-peyote
womens-leather-day-mary-jane-peyote
womens-leather-day-mary-jane-peyote
womens-leather-day-mary-jane-peyote

womens / Shoes - Sandals, Boots, Sneakers & Flats

The Day Mary Jane

$51
$128 $51
Shop more Day collection.
View full details

Sorry, this item is no longer available.

But keep an eye out—there's always a chance it will come back later.

Shop More Shoes

Overall rating: 3.853846 / 5 from 130 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

The Day Mary Jane by Peyote features buttery soft Napa leather with a sculptural-square toe and a soft elastic band, offering all-day wearability. Customers appreciate the elegant look, comfort, and quality, though some have mixed feelings about the fit and color.

Summary topics

  • Leather Material (22%): Many customers expressed satisfaction with the lovely soft leather used in the shoe, praising its comfort and luxurious feel.
  • Aesthetic Appeal (14%): Customers raved about the look of these shoes, saying they look elegant and instantly elevate any outfit.
  • Fit Accuracy (20%): Many customers expressed appreciation for the perfect fit of these shoes, finding them comfortable and true to size.
  • Shoe Design (34%): Many customers pointed out that these shoes are cute, comfortable, and of good quality, making them a popular choice.
  • Flat Design (14%): It was reported by customers that these Mary Jane ballet flats are extremely comfortable and have a cushioned insole.

Review topics: ["size","fit","color","problem","material","feel","quality","shoe","look","style","comfort","flats","leather","straps","shade","feet","band","seams","soles","mary janes","toe","break","insole","walk","piece","option","ballet","clothes","pump","distances"].

Review highlights

  • "Gorgeous ivory leather, very comfortable square fit for toes; recommend sizing up 1/2 size." — ElisabethE
  • "These shoes are instantly comfortable and the strap keeps them easily on my feet." — Maddiew
  • "The shoe fits well so soft and comfy Wish they had more colors" — Nanarose

Reviews

Quality not worth the price

"I have been very disappointed in the overall quality of these flats. For the price, I was expecting much more. After just a week of wearing the shoes, the bottom layer is peeling off and leaving pieces behind on my office floor. I would expect something like that from a $20 pair of flats, but for the price of these, I was hoping for much better durability. I’m disappointed to say the least. After now wearing the shoes for two weeks, the bottom layer has pretty much completely rubbed off to reveal what looks like cardboard type layer underneath. These shoes seem to me much more cheaply made than what Everlane is charging for them."

— Bailey E. (2/5)

Love them

"These are wonderful ballet flats. The leather is super-soft and they fit perfectly. However, as with most of my shoes, there’s a little seam on the back that rubs against the back of my heel and causes some irritation. BUT after a wear or two with a band-aid they stretched out and fit perfectly. Sizing up wouldn’t work for me. They’re well made and stylish. I’m going to see if they come in other colors. Love them!"

— Nancy H. (4/5)

Comfortable, good fit, not durable

"Pros: Comfortable, no break in required, elastic band seems durable and stretchy - not too tight that it digs in, leather is nice, good for wide feet Con: Durability I've had these ballet flats for about a month and only worn them 3-4 times to work. I walk about 15 minutes total on my commute between the streets and the subway and the soles are already wearing down that the wood is exposed. If you plan to wear these a lot and walk 3-5k steps just in daily life you may want to consider a more durable shoe."

— Nicole W. (3/5)

Classic everyday shoe

"Very classic and timeless. Love them. Able to walk 10k steps in then. Only complaint is the strap is very tight and causes swelling when worn too long or walking too much"

— Katy P. (4/5)

So cute & comfy!!

"I wear these all the time & walk a lot in them. Perfect to dress up or wear casual."

— Jackie K. (5/5)

New Shoes

"I tried on many pairs of maryjane flats and these were the best. I was hesitant about this style since but these are hands down the best. They will be great after a short break in (due to a small bunion). Leather is soft and I like that the strap is so simple. Only problem was I had to exchange since the strap on the first pair I receive were too long and twisted."

— Betsy L. (4/5)

5 stars

"These are not only beautiful to look at but they are super comfortable. They do not slip off and I can walk for miles without pain or discomfort. Great for wider feet."

— Kelly P. (5/5)

lovely shoes

"these are lovely"

— Suzanne R. (5/5)

Shopping issues

"I still have not received this shipment. This delivery company has been extremely disappointing to work with. This order will most likely be returned to you."

— Momo S. (5/5)

Broke within one hour

"I wore these for an hour and the strap came off of one shoe"

— Mackenzie W. (5/5)

Q&A

Clean Luxury. Better for You.
Clean Luxury. Better for You.
Clean Luxury. Better for You.
We believe your wardrobe should be effortless, luxurious, and crafted with real quality. That belief drives everything we do. We’ve done a lot over the past decade—but we’re just getting started. The journey toward better continues.