The Day Mary Jane
40% OFF
Regular price $77
Regular price $128 Sale price $77
Black Friday Exclusive
40% OFF
Skip to product information

The Day Mary Jane

40% OFF
Regular price $77
Regular price $128 Sale price $77
Black Friday Exclusive
View full details

Sorry, this item is no longer available.

But keep an eye out—there's always a chance it will come back later.

Overall rating: 3.9160838 / 5 from 143 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

The Day Mary Jane in Deep Brown is praised for its elegant look and buttery soft Napa leather, though opinions vary on its color, size, soles, quality, and feel. Many customers appreciate the perfect fit and the helpful strap that keeps the shoes on their feet.

Summary topics

  • Color Appeal (7%): Opinions vary on the color: some found it beautiful and striking, while others did not like it.
  • Aesthetic Appeal (14%): It was highlighted by customers that the look of these shoes is elegant and instantly elevate any outfit.
  • Leather Quality (21%): Many customers stated that the leather is lovely, soft, flexible, comfortable, and buttery soft.
  • Fit Accuracy (19%): Many customers expressed appreciation for the perfect fit of the shoes, mentioning that they fit true to size.
  • Strap Functionality (10%): Customers loved the cute and helpful strap that keeps these shoes easily on their feet and keeps them stylish.

Review topics: ["size","fit","color","problem","feel","look","material","shoe","quality","comfort","style","flats","leather","straps","seams","feet","shade","band","soles","mary janes","toe","break","insole","walk","rubbing","traction","clothes","option","cause","pump"].

Review highlights

  • "Gorgeous ivory leather, very comfortable square fit for toes; recommend sizing up 1/2 size." — ElisabethE
  • "They are comfortable, stylish, and I love that the strap is both cute and helpful in keeping them on." — C F.
  • "The leather is so soft and very lux feeling." — Hot V.

Reviews

Love this shoe

"Entirely comfortable at the moment I put it on. The shoe covers the toes well over the bony areas. Some ballet type shoes I have tried will end right at the big or little toe joint which is very uncomfortable. The elastic strap design keeps the shoe on perfectly with just the right stretch. The color is perfect neutral with jeans and this season’s palette of burgundy, fir and brown."

— Cheryl G. (5/5)

Perfect shoe for a sensitive foot

"Love this shoe. I have really sensitive feet, I get blisters from the slightest rubbing and these are so comfy. I am on my feet for a lot of the day and have no issues. Only reason why I gave them 4 stars is the sole wears down a little too fast (especially since I do like to wear them often) to the point that there is crackling. I would appreciate a more durable sole while still maintaining overall aesthetic. Such a good shoe regardless! 10/10 would recommend."

— Emma C. (4/5)

Super cute

"These are cute. I haven't been able to find flats that don't my make my feet look wierd (size 9/9.5). They are comfortable. The strap digs in a bit at first but improves as you break the shoe in."

— Bsrat M. (4/5)

"Overall good shoes. The elastic is a bit tight on the feet during the first wear but has loosened since."

— Jenny (5/5)

"High quality, soft, not stiff. Can wear right out of the box. I’m a true size 9 and they fit well (8.5 would ultimately be too tight in the toe box after wearing a few hours)."

— April (5/5)

huge blisters on my feet

"huge blisters on my feet from the back of these flats. They squeak from the inside of the shoe rubbing on my toenails. Feels like you are walking on zero padding makes walking in these uncomfortable after a few minutes"

— Amelia V. (1/5)

Day Mary Jane

"I have been looking for a flat this style for some time. I ordered both the black and blush and kept both. I found them to run true to size."

— Katelynn H. (5/5)

The shoe for every occasion

"Super cute and extremely comfortable. Can dress up or down and great with any outfit."

— Jasmine L. (5/5)

My favorite flats..square toe is

"My favorite flats..square toe is extremely comfortable.."

— debbie s. (5/5)

Super comfortable

"I have wide feet and these were really comfortable from the first wear."

— Marilynn L. (5/5)

Q&A

Better for You.
Better for You.
Better for You.
We believe your wardrobe should be effortless, luxurious, and crafted with real quality. That belief drives everything we do. We’ve done a lot over the past decade—but we’re just getting started. The journey toward better continues.