Ordered two sizes down and it fits perfectly!
"Love this perfectly oversized, boxy sweatshirt. It's so cozy and high quality. I ordered a XS, and for context, I'm a M in the Boxy Cotton sweater, so yes, I definitely recommend sizing down. I ordered a M, way too large; then ordered a S, still too baggy. The XS fit exactly how I liked it. It hit at the waist, and the sleeves were loose but not overly so. I love Everlane's quality, so once you find the right size, this sweater is perfect!"





