Fabulous
"Lovely shoe. Fit is excellent. Soft leather and very stylish."
The Day Loafer
60% OFF
Regular price
$58
Regular price
$145
Sale price
$58
Unit price
per
Shop more Day collection.
The Day Loafer
60% OFF
Regular price
$58
Regular price
$145
Sale price
$58
Unit price
per
Shop more Day collection.
Who's the lucky recipient?
Shop More Dresses
Overall rating: 4.379747 / 5 from 79 reviews.
AI Generated Review Summary
The Day Loafer in Black Suede is praised for its perfect fit, excellent feel, and high-quality materials. Customers appreciate the comfort, versatility, and stylish look, making it a popular choice for everyday wear. However, opinions on sizing vary, with some recommending going up a half size.
Summary topics
- Fit: 21%
- Feel: 11%
- Quality: 8%
- Leather: 25%
- Break-in Period: 12%
Review topics: [size, fit, color, support, quality, look, feel, legs, shape, comfort, design, price, leather, style, material, shoe, padding, cut, break, loafer, loafers, toe, pair, suede, wear, return, feet, option, nap, word].
Review highlights
- "Good quality shoe that feels right on trend." —
- "Got a size 8 a half size smaller than I normally wear, perfect fit." —
- "Beautiful soft leather and the Rum colour is perfect." —
Reviews
So comfortable and cute!
"Fits like a glove, I guess that’s why the name. Only reason I’ve docked a star is because they scuff and scar easily. I do love them tho and want more colors but I think discontinued? I want them back, I need black ones!"
I LOVE THESE SHOES!
"These shoes fit perfectly. They are comfortable and the leather is soft. I am a size 5M. After wearing these shoes, I bought a second pair. I'm so happy to find them on sale."
Too Small and Slippery
"I read through the reviews and saw that people recommended going with true size. I wear size 6 in everything - sneakers, flats, heels, etc. So I was shocked by how small these loafers are. I can even get my feet fully into them because they are so narrow. I'm not even sure if sizing up would help as the shoes would be longer, but not necessary wider. Also the soles of the shoes are very slick. It's unfortunately I got it on final sale and can't return it."
Wrong size was sent for final sale item
"I actually love this shoe and wanted to get a pair for one of my girlfriends. I ordered a size 5 but received a size 8, and despite Everlane touting an easy return/ exchange policy, the only thing I have access to is a ""RETURN GIFT"" option which I'm trying to pursue. I'm waiting to hear back from them but unsure what to do when I was sent a wrong size for a final sale item."
Most comfortable shoe ever
"Worth every penny! The quality and comfort is priceless. Definitely recommend."
Ultimate comfort
"This a great shoe. . no break- in required . . just slide your foot in and walk on. Looks great with everything and is soft and comfortable as well. I have a somewhat wide foot and often size up 1/2 size in Everlane but got these in my normal 10 and they are not even slightly snug. I check daily to see if a 10 comes back in stock black. Will also be on the lookout for summer shades. This is an ideal travel shoe-easy on and off,no laces,good sole for walking on many different surfaces and looks stylish with casual and more polished looks."
Elegant and classic
"Very narrow fit. Beautiful soft leather and the Rum colour is perfect. Definitely only for indoors wear though, as even the sole is leather. Lovely silhouette, very classy."
They peeled
"The shoes look nice and they are comfortable, but they peeled on the first day I used them. It looks like one of the shoes is made from a different kind of leather, you can see it in the picture. I like it, but I am sad it looks worn out too soon 😔"
Great work shoes
"These fit well, though they might be *slightly* too long for my foot. I bought my usual size 8. I wear Rothy's almost daily, and this is a nice option to switch it up. They go with most pants."
Q&A
Clean Luxury. Better for You.