Gorgeous shoes but FAR too big/long!
"I so wanted to love these but they are seriously huge - at least one, possibly two sizes larger than the size listed."
Gallery Square-Toe Flat
60% OFF
Regular price
$79
Regular price
$198
Sale price
$79
Unit price
per
Extra 20% Off In Cart
Gallery Square-Toe Flat
60% OFF
Regular price
$79
Regular price
$198
Sale price
$79
Unit price
per
Extra 20% Off In Cart
Who's the lucky recipient?
Overall rating: 4.5238094 / 5 from 21 reviews.
AI Generated Review Summary
Gallery Square-Toe Flat by Peyote is a versatile shoe with a 0.5in heel, high coverage upper, and a buttery soft Italian leather outsole. Customers appreciate its elegant burgundy color and buttery soft leather, though some have noted sizing issues.
Summary topics
- Color: 10%
- Leather Quality: 25%
- Build Quality: 60%
- Sizing: 30%
Review topics: [size, fit, color, shoe, quality, look, leather, heel, flats, feet, toe].
Review highlights
- "I love the squared toe, the soft leather, and the tiny round heel detail." —
- "The leather is soft right out of the box and adds a perfect pop of color for fall outfits." —
- "These shoes are gorgeous and seem to be well made; the leather is buttery soft." —
Reviews
Wrong Sizing
"I really liked these shoes. I wear a size 7. 5. I ordered a size7. 5. Yes, I got a 7. 5 BUT it was not American size 7. 5 it was European 7. 5, which is approximately 2 sizes larger. I can't return them because I bought them on sale. Very disappointed with this as it should have stated that info."
The Arch Creases Outward, Instead of Fitting Snugly.
"The Arch Creases Outward, Instead of Fitting Snugly. It needs more structure."
High Quality
"Excellent quality flat that goes well with casual and business attire. My normal Everlane size is an 8. 5, and my foot is on the narrow side. I found these shoes slightly larger than others I have ordered from Everlane."
Incredibly comfortable
"I plan to wear these during my performances. They feel like slippers but are perfect for wearing with long pants and have a bit of style to them."
Beautiful shoes
"These shoes are beautiful. I love the design and the quality. My only issue was the sizing. I am a true 8. 5 but the 8. 5 was slightly big. I tried the 8s and they were too snug! I am disappointed as I really wanted to keep these but they won't work as I am in between sizes."
Great shoe - but not for me. . .
"I saw my friend wearing this shoe and raced to the store to try them on for myself. This shoe is exactly what I have been looking for - modern style, comfortable, great quality. The problem was the fit: my feet are wide, so by the time I tried a size that was comfortable, it was too long and I kept stepping out of them. VERY disappointed - may try another model in the future. . ."
Comfortable
"I love the shoe. It fits like a glove! I prefer the look of a normal heel, but this is fine."
Fits like a glove!
"I love the squared toe, the soft leather, and the tiny round heel detail. They were quick to break in. I get tons of compliments on these shoes!"
must have skinny long feets
"could not get my foot into a half a size bigger. adorable shoe, but just not Cinderella in these shoes."
Q&A
Clean Luxury. Better for You.