womens / Shoes - Sandals, Boots, Sneakers & Flats

The Day Fisherman Sandal
$47
$188 $47
Shop more Day collection.
Extra 20% Off In Cart
75% OFF FINAL SALE
  • womens-day-fisherman-sandal-black | primary
  • womens-day-fisherman-sandal-black | alt
  • womens-day-fisherman-sandal-black
  • womens-day-fisherman-sandal-black
  • womens-day-fisherman-sandal-black
  • womens-day-fisherman-sandal-black
womens-day-fisherman-sandal-black | primary
womens-day-fisherman-sandal-black | alt
womens-day-fisherman-sandal-black
womens-day-fisherman-sandal-black
womens-day-fisherman-sandal-black
womens-day-fisherman-sandal-black

womens / Shoes - Sandals, Boots, Sneakers & Flats

The Day Fisherman Sandal

$47
$188 $47
Shop more Day collection.
Extra 20% Off In Cart
View full details

Sorry, this item is no longer available.

But keep an eye out—there's always a chance it will come back later.

Shop More Shoes

Overall rating: 4.133333 / 5 from 75 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

The Day Fisherman Sandal is handcrafted with soft Nappa leather, offering durability and timeless style. Customers praise its classic look and perfect fit, though some find the ankle strap too tight.

Summary topics

  • Product Quality (12%): Opinions vary on the quality, with some praising it as soft and good, while others criticize it as HORRIBLE.
  • Product Style (8%): It was reported by customers that the style of the product is classic, comfortable, and on trend.
  • Leather Comfort (22%): A significant number of customers stated that the leather used in the product is very soft and comfortable.
  • Product Look (12%): Customers keep praising the look of these shoes, describing them as classy, classy, and great.
  • Product Fit (18%): A significant number of customers pointed out that the fit of the product is perfect and true to size.

Review topics: ["size","fit","color","addition","design","quality","look","shoe","feel","style","leather","sandals","durability","heel","feet","toe","break","price","wear","pair","blisters","buckle","shipping","foot"].

Review highlights

  • "Perfect fit very comfortable and look great." — Fran P.
  • "Leather is so soft and the style is very comfortable and didn’t need any breaking in." — Jenn T.
  • "So comfortable, fit true to size, soft leather, style is classic and on trend." — Travelpainter

Reviews

Another stiff Shoe!!

"I don’t know what it is with Everlane and shoes! They are stiff and ungiving. The only two pairs I have ever been able to wear are the reknit boots and day flat. Every other shoe I have purchased, I have either returned or donated. why do so many people continue to deny the fact that Everlane does not do shoes well at all. I have loved many pieces of clothing, but shoes I will not waste any more money."

— Nancy P. (1/5)

Day fisherman sandal is a good shoe

"The size runs true to size and the leather is immediately comfortable. The toe is not too narrow and the overall style is feminine and easy to wear with almost any outfit. The color is great."

— Debi F. (4/5)

nice but unfortunately too small

"loved the softness but i am a typical size 5 - ordered the 5. 5 but couldn’t fit - so can’t wear them which is such a waste"

— li t. (5/5)

Style exactly as described. I

"Style exactly as described. I feel these will be perfect for spring or summer. I wore these for a few times and didn’t get any blisters. However, they are leather so they may take some time to break in. The toe box is a little narrow so I’m not sure if you would want to size up? Overall, I felt the quality of the sandals are really well made and a great style addition to my closet!"

— Hong T. (5/5)

Elegant Fisherman Sandal

"Elegant Fisherman Sandal. Size 9 works for me instead of my typical 9 1/2 with other Everlane shoes. The leather is substantial, high quality yet still molds to your feet."

— Melissa C. (5/5)

Runs really narrow in toe

"Runs really narrow in toe box. Do not buy unless you have a narrow foot"

— Linda N. (1/5)

"Fits small"

— Fatimazahra (2/5)

Great Vacation Sandals

"I love these sandals, they are so comfortable, I can walk all day on vacation"

— Belinda B. (5/5)

"I wanted a pair since last year, but they were either out of stock or $200 at other stores. I’m happy I found them at a great price and in my size."

— L (5/5)

Fit

"Not the most comfortable. Leather is a bit stiff"

— kathleen m. (3/5)

Q&A

Clean Luxury. Better for You.
Clean Luxury. Better for You.
Clean Luxury. Better for You.
We believe your wardrobe should be effortless, luxurious, and crafted with real quality. That belief drives everything we do. We’ve done a lot over the past decade—but we’re just getting started. The journey toward better continues.