"Very comfortable and great color"
The Day Buckle Mary Jane
Overall rating: 4.030303 / 5 from 66 reviews.
AI Generated Review Summary
The Day Buckle Mary Jane in Black Velvet is praised for its beautiful color, soft leather, and perfect fit. While sizing may vary, the shoes are comfortable and versatile, making them a popular choice.
Summary topics
- Color (8%): Customers loved the beautiful and striking color of the Mary Jane, which was mentioned multiple times in the reviews.
- Leather Comfort (20%): Many customers expressed satisfaction with the softness and comfort of the leather used in the product.
- Fit (17%): Based on many customers, the fit of these flats is perfect and they are a perfect fit.
- Aesthetic Appeal (20%): A significant number of customers appreciated the look of the Mary Jane shoes, finding them versatile and beautiful.
Review topics: ["size","fit","color","support","design","feel","look","price","quality","comfort","leather","wear","shape","value","details","shoe","mary janes","socks","feet","return","pair","silver","outsole","day glove","heel","break","satin","accommodates"].
Review highlights
- "The silver is versatile and looks good with everything but I would like this in red also." —
- "Perfect sizing - I'm an EU 36 and size 6 US fits great." —
- "These mary janes are very cute and comfy!" —
Reviews
Cute but I wore these
"Cute but I wore these for about 10 days and the tips/toes have already worn/scuffed. They also run a bit small and narrow. I’d size up a half size but honestly, I’d probably not buy them again as i don’t see me wearing them for more than 3 months and unfortunately having to get them repairs (if that’s even possible) or throwing them out."
"Nice shies but too small. Returned"
Cute Mary-Jane ballet flats
"The shoes are better than what I have expected. Comfy, cute, easy to dress with anything."
Nice shoes
"I am happy with my shoes and have no complaints"
color way darker than pictured
"color way darker than pictured and fit pinched me at the toes"
So cute
"Such a cute little shoe. I was a bit nervous because I have quite rectangular feet and I wasn't fully convinced that I would fit into these nicely. But the leather is dang soft and accommodates the shape of my foot well. Just don't buckle the buckle so tightly, so that the shoe can move with your foot, and actually it's very comfortable. I was surprised that there was no break in period needed; again totally thought this would be the situation. I am pleasantly surprised! The red is gorgeous; a touch bright (I would have preferred something a bit deeper and richer) but it screams summer and fun, so it still works for my wardrobe. The shoe design itself is pretty thin, so I'm unsure on the longevity in the long term, but hopefully if you have enough shoes on rotation, you can rest this pair and they might last longer?"
Must have
"I am so excited to say that this has to be the best purchase ever. The shoes feel like gloves so soft and comfortable. You will regret."
Looks great on, versatile. Usually
"Looks great on, versatile. Usually Everlane shoes run a bit big or small, depending on size and material, but this was true to my regular size. Great sale price. Just wish it had a little more arch support."
Must have
"I had purchased the black and love it so I bought it in brown trust me this shoes feels like tennis shoes."





