Button-Up Shirt in Essential Cotton

Cute

"Cute but a little tight in the arms"

— Cassie C. (3/5)

Nicely made, sizing issue

"This is a beautiful shirt. Well made. Drapes nicely. The only problem? The proportions are not right. It fits me perfectly except in the bust. Buttons puckering. I do not have a large bust in proportion to the rest of my body. Ordering a size up would be too big everywhere else. I have never had this problem before. It’s very disappointing because the clothing in this site is very nice. This is my first purchase. But I won’t order more because of this sizing issue. I have ordered clothes for decades from many reputable sites. Never had this problem before."

— Susan M. (3/5)

Love these shirts

"These shirts fit very nicely, and look great. I did size up since I have a larger chest and I wanted the buttons to lay well, I am a 34ddd and I got a large. I hope more colors are available in the future, I already have all three of these basic colors."

— Kristi T. (5/5)

Love this shirt!

"This shirt is perfect. The cut, length and slightly fitted shape. I’m 5’8” and 125 lbs and the small was perfect. I was sad when they sold out and hope more colors come in for spring!"

— Rebekah P. (5/5)

Runs Absurdly Small

"Runs Insanely Small compared to all of the other items I’ve purchased through Everlane in the same size – XXS Had to Return both shirts in this cut I am 5 foot two and I weigh 90 pounds. This shirt was too tight to button."

— Karie G. (1/5)

"Love it! Soft, comfortable fabric, looks great under a casual sweater or a blazer. I did size up-I’m usually a large 12-14, but ordered the extra large based on reviews and it fits perfectly, so i would characterize as a slim fit."

— Joy (5/5)

Not great

"Stiff fabric, long arms, and pulling at the buttons."

— Hannah Z. (3/5)

"Wish the buttons were color matched to the fabric. Looked very cheap, had to return"

— Sarah (3/5)

Great basic

"These are great shirts, very flattering. I sized up to a large due to 34ddd chest."

— Kristi T. (5/5)

Perfect fit

"I love this shirt. The color is flattering and the fit is perfect. I received multiple compliments the first time I wore it. Please make more colors, Everlane!"

— Casey N. (5/5)