The Day Mary Jane

Love this shoe

"Entirely comfortable at the moment I put it on. The shoe covers the toes well over the bony areas. Some ballet type shoes I have tried will end right at the big or little toe joint which is very uncomfortable. The elastic strap design keeps the shoe on perfectly with just the right stretch. The color is perfect neutral with jeans and this season’s palette of burgundy, fir and brown."

— Cheryl G. (5/5)

Perfect shoe for a sensitive foot

"Love this shoe. I have really sensitive feet, I get blisters from the slightest rubbing and these are so comfy. I am on my feet for a lot of the day and have no issues. Only reason why I gave them 4 stars is the sole wears down a little too fast (especially since I do like to wear them often) to the point that there is crackling. I would appreciate a more durable sole while still maintaining overall aesthetic. Such a good shoe regardless! 10/10 would recommend."

— Emma C. (4/5)

"High quality, soft, not stiff. Can wear right out of the box. I’m a true size 9 and they fit well (8.5 would ultimately be too tight in the toe box after wearing a few hours)."

— April (5/5)

"Terrible quality shoes. I have only worn for a couple months, going from my house to my office where I sit at a desk all day. The leather on the back heels is peeling already and the soles are completely worn through. For the price and little amount that I wear them, I thought they would hold up. Also, the strap on one of them broke my second time wearing them, so i ended up just cutting both off (-:"

— Bella (2/5)

THE DAY MARY JANE

"A perfect fit and comfortable enough for a long day of walking! Waiting for the restock of the canvas color in my size to buy another pair!"

— Isabella C. (5/5)

Comfortable and chic

"Very comfortable and true to size. Can be worn dress down or dress up."

— Marlene P. (5/5)

Quality not worth the price

"I have been very disappointed in the overall quality of these flats. For the price, I was expecting much more. After just a week of wearing the shoes, the bottom layer is peeling off and leaving pieces behind on my office floor. I would expect something like that from a $20 pair of flats, but for the price of these, I was hoping for much better durability. I’m disappointed to say the least. After now wearing the shoes for two weeks, the bottom layer has pretty much completely rubbed off to reveal what looks like cardboard type layer underneath. These shoes seem to me much more cheaply made than what Everlane is charging for them."

— Bailey E. (2/5)

Love them

"These are wonderful ballet flats. The leather is super-soft and they fit perfectly. However, as with most of my shoes, there’s a little seam on the back that rubs against the back of my heel and causes some irritation. BUT after a wear or two with a band-aid they stretched out and fit perfectly. Sizing up wouldn’t work for me. They’re well made and stylish. I’m going to see if they come in other colors. Love them!"

— Nancy H. (4/5)

Comfortable, good fit, not durable

"Pros: Comfortable, no break in required, elastic band seems durable and stretchy - not too tight that it digs in, leather is nice, good for wide feet Con: Durability I've had these ballet flats for about a month and only worn them 3-4 times to work. I walk about 15 minutes total on my commute between the streets and the subway and the soles are already wearing down that the wood is exposed. If you plan to wear these a lot and walk 3-5k steps just in daily life you may want to consider a more durable shoe."

— Nicole W. (3/5)

Classic everyday shoe

"Very classic and timeless. Love them. Able to walk 10k steps in then. Only complaint is the strap is very tight and causes swelling when worn too long or walking too much"

— Katy P. (4/5)