The Penny Loafer
70% OFF
Regular price $59
Regular price $198 Sale price $59
70% OFF FINAL SALE
Skip to product information

The Penny Loafer

70% OFF
Regular price $59
Regular price $198 Sale price $59
View full details

Sorry, this item is no longer available.

But keep an eye out—there's always a chance it will come back later.

Overall rating: 2.659091 / 5 from 44 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

The Penny Loafer in Black is praised for its classic loafer silhouette and premium leather construction. While some customers found the fit to be poor, others appreciated the attractive design and welt detailing.

Summary topics

  • Design: 56%
  • Fit: 40%

Review topics: ["fit","look","length","shoe","quality","style","shape","loafers","feel","leather","texture","exception","care","information","photos","feet","slip"].

Review highlights

  • "The shoe is really attractive, and comfortable."Steppebgc
  • "I like the shiny leather - it's different and fun adding a interesting texture to an outfit."Nadine W.
  • "The initial fit for me was quite snug so - unlike most my winter loafers - I'm able to wear these sockless!"Everlove2002

Reviews

Classic

"I was looking for a new classic loafers to replace a worn out pair. I like these better than my old pair! They are a bit stiff as some other reviews mentioned. But even so, I have worn them multiple times for the full day and had no discomfort or blisters. I also receive many compliments anytime I wear them the are a tad shiny, almost like patent leather."

Susan T. (5/5)

Beautiful loafers

"The shoes are just beautiful very comfortable but a bit too large for me. Had to put insole."

merav r. (5/5)

Loafers

"I purchased the black as well as brown loafers. I got serious blisters wearing the black ones for the first time. Unfortunately, I got these on sale and cannot return them. Very disappointing."

Donna D. (1/5)

GREAT SHOE

"The shoes arrived looking like what was advertised and fit just like I'd hoped."

Delores R. (5/5)

Black loafers

"The black shoes gave me 3 blisters the first and only time I wore them. They are very stiff and tight. While they are beautiful, I cannot wear them."

Donna D. (1/5)

Bad material

"Material is Very hard. Cannot be broken in. I wish I could return it. Disappointed"

Pafica W. (1/5)

Beautiful but stiff

"I haven’t worn these much, but I am a little nervous to take them out because they are extremely stiff and tight in the heel."

Tara L. (4/5)

"A little stiff but hopefully with soften with wear. Otherwise beautiful!"

Lisa (5/5)

The Heels Slip

"Very uncomfortable. I have ballet slippers from Everlane and they fit perfectly, so I bought these loafers on sale in exactly the same size. But they do not fit; my heels slip up and out when I try to walk. I am very disappointed as they were on sale and are not returnable. Also, the leather is very hard."

Careymcm (1/5)

The Heels Slip

"Very uncomfortable. I have ballet slippers from Everlane and they fit perfectly, so I bought these loafers on sale in exactly the same size. But they do not fit; my heels slip up and out when I try to walk. I am very disappointed as they were on sale and are not returnable. Also, the leather is very hard."

Careymcm (1/5)

Q&A

Clean Luxury. Better for You.
Clean Luxury. Better for You.
Clean Luxury. Better for You.
We believe your wardrobe should be effortless, luxurious, and crafted with real quality. That belief drives everything we do. We’ve done a lot over the past decade—but we’re just getting started. The journey toward better continues.