bad quality
"Sole broke after ~50 days of wear. Cute but terrible quality, can't trust the brand at all, especially now that they're owned by Shein."
$120.00 away from free express shipping
No returns or exchanges on final sale.
Catch of the day
Immaculately handcrafted with incredibly soft Nappa leather, the Day Fisherman Sandal features unmatched long-lasting durability with its square-toe, inset circular shaped heel, adjustable leather buckle straps, and a padded insole for comfort and timeless style. Talk about a win-win. This sandal uses leather sourced from a tannery rated Gold by the Leather Working Group (LWG)—the highest rating a tannery can receive for demonstrating best practices in environmental compliance and performance capabilities.Overall rating: 4.0921054 / 5 from 76 reviews.
The Day Fisherman Sandal is praised for its classy look, perfect fit, and timeless style. While some customers appreciate the luxurious leather, others have mixed opinions about the design and quality. The adjustable leather buckle straps add comfort, but a few have noted issues with the ankle strap being too tight.
Review topics: [size, fit, color, addition, look, style, feel, pair, design, quality, leather, shoe, durability, sandals, heel, feet, toe, break, price, wear, buckle, foot, blisters, shipping].
"Sole broke after ~50 days of wear. Cute but terrible quality, can't trust the brand at all, especially now that they're owned by Shein."
"I don’t know what it is with Everlane and shoes! They are stiff and ungiving. The only two pairs I have ever been able to wear are the reknit boots and day flat. Every other shoe I have purchased, I have either returned or donated. why do so many people continue to deny the fact that Everlane does not do shoes well at all. I have loved many pieces of clothing, but shoes I will not waste any more money."
"The size runs true to size and the leather is immediately comfortable. The toe is not too narrow and the overall style is feminine and easy to wear with almost any outfit. The color is great."
"loved the softness but i am a typical size 5 - ordered the 5. 5 but couldn’t fit - so can’t wear them which is such a waste"
"Style exactly as described. I feel these will be perfect for spring or summer. I wore these for a few times and didn’t get any blisters. However, they are leather so they may take some time to break in. The toe box is a little narrow so I’m not sure if you would want to size up? Overall, I felt the quality of the sandals are really well made and a great style addition to my closet!"
"Elegant Fisherman Sandal. Size 9 works for me instead of my typical 9 1/2 with other Everlane shoes. The leather is substantial, high quality yet still molds to your feet."
"Runs really narrow in toe box. Do not buy unless you have a narrow foot"
"Fits small"
"I love these sandals, they are so comfortable, I can walk all day on vacation"
"I wanted a pair since last year, but they were either out of stock or $200 at other stores. I’m happy I found them at a great price and in my size."